Category Archives: Sundry

MFDJ 10/19/23: The Rosenthal Murder

Today’s Grifting Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

Early Tuesday morning, July 16, 1912, New York City was sweating through a brutal heat wave. Gambler Herman “Beansie” Rosenthal was spending his last earthly moments in the Hotel Metropole, a popular gathering spot for the sporting set, at 143 West Forty-Third Street. He was nursing his beverage of choice: a horse’s neck—cold ginger ale with a lemon twist. The next day he was scheduled to appear before a grand jury to tell all he knew about the illegal gambling taking place in Manhattan. There were a lot of people on both sides of the law who would have preferred that Rosenthal keep his mouth shut.


The old Hotel Metropole

Around two A.M. he was told that he was wanted outside. Rosenthal obligingly complied, striding through the lobby toward the street, where he was summoned by name. When he approached a man in the shadows, he was hit by four gunshots—one in the neck, one in the nose, and two in the head. Four gunmen sped off in a gray Packard, leaving Rosenthal to die in the sweltering street.


Beansie Rosenthal

During the months leading up to his murder, Rosenthal’s fortunes were on the downturn. The previous autumn, he borrowed $5,000 from “Big” Tim Sullivan, the powerful Tammany Hall politician who controlled gambling operations in the Tenderloin, the rough-and-tough neighborhood that had expanded to surround Times Square. At one time, Rosenthal had run the popular gaming room at Sullivan’s famed Hesper Club. Rosenthal hoped to recapture his lost prestige by opening a new, luxurious casino at 104 West Forty-Fifth Street. The club, however, was shuttered just four days after it opened. Cops, under the command of Inspector Cornelius Hayes, raided the joint because, according to Rosenthal, he refused to pay the policemen the necessary tribute to stay in business.

Since nobody made money when a casino closed down, Rosenthal reluctantly reached out to Lieutenant Charles Becker. He was the commander of one of the NYPD’s three Strong Arm Squads, which were special units formed by Police Commissioner Rhinelander Waldo to suppress vice in the Tenderloin. To most casual observers, Becker seemed to perform his job with great enthusiasm, but to those in the know, Becker could be bought. Rosenthal wanted to know if some arrangement could be worked out. Becker agreed, provided Rosenthal cut him in on the action.

Unfortunately, Becker could not give Rosenthal complete immunity from prosecution. When Police Commissioner Waldo gave Becker a direct order to raid Rosenthal’s nightclub on April 17, 1912, he had no choice but to comply. Although Becker arranged for Rosenthal to be away from the casino, he arrested Rosenthal’s teenaged nephew. The nephew’s subsequent indictment, and his own inability to reopen his gambling den, outraged Rosenthal. This set him and Becker on a collision course that would cost both of them their lives.

Since Becker could not, or would not, help him, Rosenthal decided to turn on him. He took his grievances to the Manhattan district attorney, Charles Whitman, a priggish prosecutor with political ambitions. At first, Whitman ignored his caterwauling until Herbert Bayard Swope, a young and ambitious newspaperman for Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World, obtained Rosenthal’s signed affidavit spelling out Becker’s outsized appetite for graft.

With Rosenthal now lying on a morgue slab, Whitman was left in an unenviable quandary. Who had killed Rosenthal, and how could Whitman now prosecute Becker, a purportedly dirty cop, without a star witness?

The solution became apparent when Whitman, at Swope’s urging, granted immunity to four suspects the police apprehended who admitted playing key roles in the scheme. Three of those suspects—Jack “Bald Jack Rose” Rosenzweig, Louis “Bridgey” Webber, and Harry Vallon—testified that they hired the getaway car and the shooters. They were ostensibly paid $1,000 at Becker’s behest to do the hit. Becker even pointed out Rosenthal in front of the Metropole for the assassins.

Bald Jack’s claims were particularly devastating to Becker. He alleged that upon seeing Rosenthal’s lifeless body, Becker remarked, “It was a pleasing sight to me to look and see that squealing Jew there, and if it were not for the presence of Whitman, I would have cut out his tongue and hung it up on the Times building as a warning to future squealers.”

The four shooters, all members of the Lenox Avenue Gang, were not afforded any leniency by Whitman. Harry “Gyp the Blood” Horowitz, Louis “Lefty Louie” Rosenberg, Francisco “Dago Frank” Cirofici, and Jacob “White Lewis” Seidenshiner were convicted and subsequently electrocuted an April 13, 1914.


“Lefty Louis” Rosenberg and Gyp the Blood (seated in front row) after being arrested by police (standing)

Becker was tried separately. Although he did not testify on his own behalf, much was made by the prosecution of the fact that he had deposited nearly $30,000 in several different banks during the months leading up to Rosenthal’s murder. His various convoluted explanations about how he accumulated to much money in such a short period of time (on a salary of $2,000 a year) only made him seem more dishonest. He was found guilty and sentenced to die. However, a scathing Court of Appeals ruling in February 1914 tossed out the verdict and ordered a new trial on the grounds that Judge John W. Goff had been biased against him and his defense team.

A new judge, the esteemed Samuel Seabury, presided over a retrial that ended with the same results. Becker was again found guilty and sentenced to death. This time, the courts declined to intervene.

While waiting for his appointment with death in Sing Sing’s bleak “Death House,” Becker became friendly with a fellow death row inmate as notorious as himself, Father Hans Schmidt, the only Catholic priest in America ever to be sentenced to death.

Becker insisted he was innocent until the very end. “I am not guilty by deed, or conspiracy, or any other way, of the death of Rosenthal,” Becker announced, as he prepared to die. Becker’s third wife, the former Helen Lynch, a public school teacher, had petitioned the governor to spare her husband’s life. Unfortunately for her, the newly elected governor was none other than Charles Whitman, the very same prosecutor who had twice convicted Becker. His sentence was carried out in what witnesses described as a “botched” electrocution because it required more than eight agonizing minutes for Becker to die.


Charles Becker’s Mugshot at Sing-Sing

In response, Mrs. Becker became so outraged, she arranged to have a silver plate engraved with the inscription affixed to her husband’s coffin. It read, “Charles Becker. Murdered July 30, 1915. By Governor Whitman.” It was only after the threat of arrest for criminal libel that the plate was removed prior to Becker’s burial at Woodlawn Cemetery in the Bronx.

Several authors have argued how Becker was likely innocent and was framed with manufactured evidence by the opportunists Swope and Whitman. Rosenthal’s obstreperousness made him a tempting target, not only for Becker but for other corrupt cops and unsavory gamblers, many of whom were incensed he would take a private spat public, as well as the politicians they paid off to stay in business.

Culled from: Undisclosed Files of the Police

The Hotel Metropole building is still standing – albeit much less charming than it used to be. It is now the Casablanca restaurant.

 

Weegee Du Jour!

Weegee was the pseudonym of Arthur Fellig (June 12, 1899 – December 26, 1968), a photographer and photojournalist, known for his stark black and white street photography. Weegee worked in Manhattan, New York City’s Lower East Side as a press photographer during the 1930s and ’40s, and he developed his signature style by following the city’s emergency services and documenting their activity. Much of his work depicted unflinchingly realistic scenes of urban life, crime, injury and death.

Here’s a photo from the book Weegee’s New York: Photographs, 1935-1960:


“Mail Early for Delivery Before Christmas”

 

Andersonville Prisoner Diary Entry Du Jour!

This is the continuation of the 1864 diary of Andersonville prisoner Private George A. Hitchcock (see the archived version for all entries up until now).

Here’s today’s entry:

July 3d. Very hot. Roll was called throughout the camp. Our detachment lost their rations on account of the absence of half a dozen men, so our extra rations of yesterday were very opportune.

Culled from: Andersonville: Giving Up the Ghost

MFDJ 10/11/23: Roman Burials

Today’s Carefully Preserved Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

The Romans practiced cremation up until AD 200, when it began to fall out of favor. Under the influence of Christianity, which emphasized the physical resurrection of the body, the first wooden coffins were introduced. Christian burial rites, derived from Judaic law, included washing the corpse before burial and anointing it with oils. Once the corpse had been washed, and the orifices plugged to prevent leakage, it was wrapped in a shroud. The belief persisted that a body must be entire for resurrection on Judgement Day, so, when possible, items such as missing teeth and even amputated limbs were carefully preserved and buried with the corpse.


Roman wooden coffin

Traditionally, bodies went on display for at least two days before burial, so that mourners could pay their last respects, and the important practice of ‘watching’, also derived from ancient Jewish ritual, might be observed. ‘Watching’ also seemed to develop from a natural reluctance to leave the dead person to whom so much care had been devoted during their final hours.  [Just a wild guess, but maybe ‘watching’ also derived from a natural reluctance to bury people alive? – DeSpair]

Culled from: Necropolis: London and Its Dead

 

Vintage Medical Illustration Du Jour!

A female patient with unilateral ichthyosis, covering her abdomen, shoulders, neck, elbow, hand and thigh.

Culled from: The Sick Rose

 

Andersonville Prisoner Diary Entry Du Jour!

This is the continuation of the 1864 diary of Andersonville prisoner Private George A. Hitchcock (see the archived version for all entries up until now).

Here’s today’s entry:

June 25th. Very hot. Rations of raw meal and meat, but no wood to cook them with, so we eat our meat raw. I had a good wash at the creek to-day, though without soap. Rows in camp are increasing, and it presents a scene like a second Babel.

Culled from: Andersonville: Giving Up the Ghost

MFDJ 11/28/2021: Flickering Doom

Today’s Flickering Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

In the wake of the heat flash and the blast wave from the atomic bomb set off over Hiroshima at 8:15 a.m. on Monday, August 6, 1945, came fire, caused partly by the direct radiated heat from the bomb, partly by other causes – gas leaks, electrical sparking and so forth. A nightmare was faced by the wounded who had survived the flash and the blast but who were trapped in the rubble of the devastated city. Yamaguchi, a ship designer, was about one and a half miles from ground zero:

As the dust blew away and my surroundings became visible, I saw what seemed to be thousands of tiny, flickering lamps all over the street and in the fields. They were little circles of flame, each about the size of a doughnut. Myriads of them were hanging on the leaves of the potato plants.

Air rushing in to feed the flames of these many fires caused a firestorm to develop. As was noted by the British survey, fires burnt with an unusual ferocity and thoroughness and many injured burnt to death, unable to escape them. Survivors became frantic in the struggle to get away from the flames and this created its own series of tragedies:

As I went further, I came upon a reservoir used for the prevention of fire. In the reservoir there were numberless corpses piled one upon another. It was a hill of dead bodies in green. All of these people must have jumped into the reservoir because of the heat.


A rare image of the Hiroshima firestorm.

At the moment that the bomb detonated over Hiroshima, it is thought that there may have been about 320,000 people present in the city. The heat flash, the blast wave and the subsequent fires probably accounted for 80,000 of them in the first few hours, but those that survived were, as the Los Alamos scientists thought, in a ‘new world’:

Although I knew the city well, it was actually difficult to find my way, for all the familiar landmarks had gone, and the streets I had often walked were now buried in debris and ashes.

The survivors were now faced with the problem of trying to avoid the flames and go to the aid of friends, family, loved ones and strangers; or simply to escape:

The whole city was burning. Black smoke was billowing up and we could hear the sound of big things exploding… The fires were burning.  There was a strange smell all over.  Blue-green balls of fire were drifting around. I had a terrible lonely feeling that everybody else in the world was dead and only we were left alive.I was determined not to escape without my mother. But the flames were steadily spreading and my clothes were already on fire and I couldn’t stand it any longer. So screaming, ‘Mummy, Mummy!’ I ran wildly into the middle of the flames. No matter how far I went it was a sea of fire all around and there was no way to escape. So beside myself I jumped into our water tank. The sparks were falling everywhere so I put a piece of tin over my head to keep out the fire. The water in the tank was hot like a bath. Beside me there were four or five other people who were all calling someone’s name. While I was in the water tank everything became like a dream and sometime or other I became unconscious… Five days after that I learned that mother had finally died just as I had left her.

I left my mother there and went off… I was later told by a neighbor that my mother had been found dead, face down in a water tank… very close to the spot where I had left her… if I had been a little older or stronger I could have rescued her… Even now I still hear my mother’s voice calling me to help her.  (Schoolgirl)

Culled from: Eye-Witness Hiroshima

 

An Incredible Tale!

I have an incredible tale to share with you, so strap-on your seatbelt!

It all began when my dear friend Eleanor posted the following photo and caption on my Facebook page:

Wish they all could be Minnesota girls!

Just look at that smug smirk!  What sort of mayhem do you suppose our Bertha was involved in? I suggested perhaps she kicked a man in the nether regions with her pointy boots; my friend Jim suggested perhaps she’d poisoned her husband; I suggested that would still be called “murder”, not “mayhem”.  We continued our debate for awhile until I thought, why not do some sleuthing?  I had a name and a year after all, so I went to Newspapers.Com and found the following clue from a 1908 San Jose, California newspaper:

At this point, we knew that she may have been a native of Minnesota, but she did her crime in San Jose.  We also had a date of the crime, so I did some more searching and found this:

The clues of exactly what sort of mayhem Bertha did are abundant here!  “Every person who unlawfully and maliciously deprives a human being of a member of his body or renders it useless… is guilty of mayhem.”  Additional clues come from the description of the attack:  “Mrs. Boronda without warning attacked her husband in the dark with a razor, maiming him fearfully.”

At this point I thought, did she Bobbitt him???  I think she Bobbitted him!!!

And lo and behold!

Indeed, she Lorena’d before Lorena!  Now we know why her mug looked so smug!

On Ancestry I found additional photos from the San Quentin mug shot collection.  I know, RIGHT???  THERE’S A SAN QUENTIN MUGSHOT COLLECTION ONLINE!  SQUEE!!!  Stay tuned for ‘Beaucoup De Détenus Du Jour!”

Additional sleuthing found that she was divorced by her much-abused husband in 1923.  Yeah, I know – he stayed marry to her for an additional 16 years after she “frightfully maimed” him?  Bit of a pushover, wasn’t he?  Of course, I suppose he didn’t have a lot to offer a girl after, you know…

Bertha remarried but apparently didn’t re-Bobbitt.  She died in 1950 at the age of 72.

Find-A-Grave Entry

“She was just a saleslady from Minnesota…”

As for the much-suffering Narciso, he did remarry and he ended up living until 1940, when he died at the age of 72.
Find-A-Grave Entry

 

Memento Mori!

Michael Marano recommends a page from MessyNessyChic.Com which details some glorious memento mori that we all wished we had in our collection.  Try not to be too jealous!


A Brief Compendium of Mesmerizing and Macabre Memento Mori

MFDJ 08/01/2021: The Premature Death of Ernie Kovacs

Today’s Way Out Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

Talented, way-out Ernie Kovacs – whose range of comedy characters included lisping poet Percy Dovetonsils – once said, “I like to be onstage because nobody can bother me there. Lawyers, process servers, insurance salesman – anyone.” While he would make several movies, it was on TV that the burly Kovacs best demonstrated his rich and inventive comedy, most of which he wrote himself.

He and actress Edie Adams married in 1954 and moved to California in 1959 when Columbia Pictures signed Kovacs to a four-year contract at $100,000 a picture.  In 1960 he appeared on screen in five features, ranging from Our Man in Havana to Strangers When We Meet. In what proved to be his last movie, Sail a Crooked Ship (1961), he was cast as a menacing villain.


Edie Adams and Ernie Kovacs

In early 1961, Kovacs was acting in a TV pilot (A Pony for Chris with Buster Keaton) and was discussing a feature-film production deal with Alec Guinness. Then came January 12, 1962, the day that ended everything for Kovacs.

The Kovacs were invited to director Billy Wilder’s apartment on Wilshire Boulevard to celebrate the christening of Milton and Ruth Berle’s new son, Michael. Edie drove to the party alone in her Corvair station wagon, since Ernie had been busy working on the TV pilot all day and was to meet her there. He drove to Wilder’s place in his white Rolls Royce. At 1:20 A.M., Ernie and Edie left the get-together. He offered French movie star Yves Montand a ride, but Montand decided to go with the Berles. Slightly drunk, Ernie drove off in the station wagon (which Edie hated to drive), asking his wife to drive the Rolls home. As he roared through the wet night, his vehicle smashed into the concrete triangle at the intersection of Beverly Glen and Santa Monica Boulevard. The impact spun the car around and wrapped it around a pole. Kovacs died instantly of a basal skull fracture. He was found dead with a Cuban cigar a few inches from his hand. Had he not been momentarily distracted while trying to light the stogie, he would have been 43 on January 23, 1962.

Unaware of the tragedy, Edie had driven home. When she heard the bad news, she refused to believe her husband was gone until Jack Lemmon went to the morgue and confirmed that he was indeed dead. Edie asked Lemmon to put several Havana cigars in Ernie’s pocket before the burial.

The funeral was held on January 18, 1962, at the Beverly Hills Presbyterian Church, and attended by a host of celebrities. Pallbearers included Jack Lemmon, Frank Sinatra, Billy Wilder, and Dean Martin. The comedian was buried at Forest Lawn Memorial Park in Hollywood Hills, California, where his marker reads: “Ernie Kovacs 1919-1962. Nothing in Moderation. We all loved him.” The hard-working Edie was saddled with $600,000 in gambling and tax debts that took her years to pay off.


Kovacs dead at the scene


The battered Corvair

Mandatory Credit: Photo by Anonymous/AP/Shutterstock (6628352a)
Dotted line in this view of Santa Monica Boulevard course taken by a skidding station wagon driven by comedian Ernie Kovacs and the power point into which he crashed, Los Angeles, Calif. Kovacs died in the wreckage. He was enroute home when the vehicle went out of control on wet pavement
Ernie Kovacs Crash Site 1962, Los Angeles, USA

Scene of the Crash – it looks nothing like this now.

Culled from: The Hollywood Book of Death

MFDJ 06/20/2021: A Pressing Issue

Today’s Tortur’d Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

In 17th century England there was an interpretation of the law by many accused persons that while their goods and chattels would be forfeit to the king on being executed, nevertheless should they die while being persuaded to plead, their worldly goods would pass to their families, as no death sentence had been passed on them by the court. The historian Holinshead reported it as:

Such fellons as stand mute and speake not at their arraignmente are pressed to death by huge weights laid up on a board that lieth over their brest, and a sharp stone under their backs, and these commonlie hold their peace, thereby to save their goods unto their wives and children; which if they were condemned, should be confiscated to the king.

One man who was prepared to die slowly and painfully rather than deprive his successors of their birthright was George Strangeways, a Royalist major in the Civil War.  Rather than have his estate confiscated by the victorious Roundheads, he leased it to his sister Mabellah, with whom he lived. Mabellah, however, got married, and George, fearing the loss of his possessions to the newcomer, murdered him. Determined to defy the authorities to the bitter end, he remained mute at his trial in February 1658. The court sentenced him to be pressed, but vindictively ordered that the planks on which the victim usually lay should be omitted, so that by lying on an earthen floor, death would be delayed.

Another unfortunate soul being pressed to death.

The press at that time was a triangular board, the acute angle of which was positioned over the victim’s heart, and George Strangeways’ suffering must have been extreme, before the merciful end came.

He was prohibited that usuall Favour in that kind, to have a piece of Timber layed under his back to Accelerate its penetration, and the Assistants laid on a first weight, which finding it too light for a sudden Execution, many of those standing by added their own weight to disburthen him of his pain. In the space of eight or ten minutes at the most, his unfettered Soul left her tortur’d Mansion. And he from that violent Paroxisme fell into the quiet sleep of Death.

Culled from: Rack, Rope and Red Hot Pincers

 

Ask a Mortician

At last, all those questions you’ve always wanted to ask a mortician are finally answered!  (Thanks to Marco McClean for the link.)

Ask a Mortician

MFDJ 04/04/2021: Controversial Handwashing

Today’s Pestilent Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

This is the story of a man whose ideas could have saved a lot of lives and spared countless numbers of women and newborns’ feverish and agonizing deaths.

You’ll notice I said “could have.”

The year was 1846, and our would-be hero was a Hungarian doctor named Ignaz Semmelweis.

Semmelweis was a man of his time, according to Justin Lessler, an assistant professor at Johns Hopkins School of Public Health.


Ignaz Semmelweis: Man Before His Time

It was a time Lessler describes as “the start of the golden age of the physician scientist,” when physicians were expected to have scientific training.

So doctors like Semmelweis were no longer thinking of illness as an imbalance caused by bad air or evil spirits. They looked instead to anatomy. Autopsies became more common, and doctors got interested in numbers and collecting data.

The young Dr. Semmelweis was no exception. When he showed up for his new job in the maternity clinic at the General Hospital in Vienna, he started collecting some data of his own. Semmelweis wanted to figure out why so many women in maternity wards were dying from puerperal fever — commonly known as childbed fever.

He studied two maternity wards in the hospital. One was staffed by all male doctors and medical students, and the other was staffed by female midwives. And he counted the number of deaths on each ward.

When Semmelweis crunched the numbers, he discovered that women in the clinic staffed by doctors and medical students died at a rate nearly five times higher than women in the midwives’ clinic.

But why?

Semmelweis went through the differences between the two wards and started ruling out ideas.

Right away he discovered a big difference between the two clinics.

In the midwives’ clinic, women gave birth on their sides. In the doctors’ clinic, women gave birth on their backs. So he had women in the doctors’ clinic give birth on their sides. The result, Lessler says, was “no effect.”

Then Semmelweis noticed that whenever someone on the ward died of childbed fever, a priest would walk slowly through the doctors’ clinic, past the women’s beds with an attendant ringing a bell. This time Semmelweis theorized that the priest and the bell ringing so terrified the women after birth that they developed a fever, got sick and died. [Leave it to a 19th century man to think a woman who survived the rigors of childbirth would be scared to death by the ringing of a bell! – DeSpair]

So Semmelweis had the priest change his route and ditch the bell. Lessler says, “It had no effect.”

By now, Semmelweis was frustrated. He took a leave from his hospital duties and traveled to Venice. He hoped the break and a good dose of art would clear his head.

When Semmelweis got back to the hospital, some sad but important news was waiting for him. One of his colleagues, a pathologist, had fallen ill and died. It was a common occurrence, according to Jacalyn Duffin, who teaches the history of medicine at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario.

“This often happened to the pathologists,” Duffin says. “There was nothing new about the way he died. He pricked his finger while doing an autopsy on someone who had died from childbed fever.” And then he got very sick himself and died.

Semmelweis studied the pathologist’s symptoms and realized the pathologist died from the same thing as the women he had autopsied. This was a revelation: Childbed fever wasn’t something only women in childbirth got sick from. It was something other people in the hospital could get sick from as well.

But it still didn’t answer Semmelweis’ original question: “Why were more women dying from childbed fever in the doctors’ clinic than in the midwives’ clinic?”

Duffin says the death of the pathologist offered him a clue.

“The big difference between the doctors’ ward and the midwives’ ward is that the doctors were doing autopsies and the midwives weren’t,” she says.

So Semmelweis hypothesized that there were cadaverous particles, little pieces of corpse, that students were getting on their hands from the cadavers they dissected. And when they delivered the babies, these particles would get inside the women who would develop the disease and die.

If Semmelweis’ hypothesis was correct, getting rid of those cadaverous particles should cut down on the death rate from childbed fever.

So he ordered his medical staff to start cleaning their hands and instruments not just with soap but with a chlorine solution. Chlorine, as we know today, is about the best disinfectant there is. Semmelweis didn’t know anything about germs. He chose the chlorine because he thought it would be the best way to get rid of any smell left behind by those little bits of corpse.

Ignaz Semmelweis washing his hands in chlorinated lime water before operating.

And when he imposed this, the rate of childbed fever fell dramatically.

What Semmelweis had discovered is something that still holds true today: Hand-washing is one of the most important tools in public health. It can keep kids from getting the flu, prevent the spread of disease and keep infections at bay.

You’d think everyone would be thrilled. Semmelweis had solved the problem! But they weren’t thrilled.

For one thing, doctors were upset because Semmelweis’ hypothesis made it look like they were the ones giving childbed fever to the women.

And Semmelweis was not very tactful. He publicly berated people who disagreed with him and made some influential enemies.

Eventually the doctors gave up the chlorine hand-washing, and Semmelweis — he lost his job.

Semmelweis kept trying to convince doctors in other parts of Europe to wash with chlorine, but no one would listen to him.

Even today, convincing health care providers to take hand-washing seriously is a challenge. Hundreds of thousands of hospital patients get infections each year, infections that can be deadly and hard to treat. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says hand hygiene is one of the most important ways to prevent these infections.

Over the years, Semmelweis got angrier and eventually even strange. There’s been speculation he developed a mental condition brought on by possibly syphilis or even Alzheimer’s. And in 1865, when he was only 47 years old, Ignaz Semmelweis was committed to a mental asylum.

The sad end to the story is that Semmelweis was probably beaten in the asylum and eventually died of sepsis, a potentially fatal complication of an infection in the bloodstream — basically, it’s the same disease Semmelweis fought so hard to prevent in those women who died from childbed fever.

Culled from: NPR

 

Something Interesting

The always-wonderful Michael Marano wrote to share a wonderful way to waste a few hours: the Livejournal (remember that?) page All Things Amazing.  If you’re fond of eclectic photographs and ephemera, please visit!

MFDJ 05/17/19: Olde Tyme Dangers

Today’s Deadly Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

In October 1926 Chief Medical Examiner Charles Norris issued his yearly analysis of deaths in New York City. He’d instituted that procedure when taking office. Insurance companies around the country now requested the report.

This one confirmed that automobiles and their often-drunken drivers remained the city’s greatest killers, taking 1,272 lives in a year. There had also been 984 suicides (almost 400 by illuminating gas), 356 murders (mostly shootings), and 696 alcohol-related deaths. There was also the elevator problem: 87 people had died in elevator accidents during the year – 47 falls into open shafts, 36 crushed by the doors, three killed when cables broke and the machines fell.


Murdermobiles!

Then six people had been killed playing baseball, six people had died in sleighing accidents, football had killed one, three had died in fistfights, and eight people had lost their lives in diving accidents. The list could go on and on – and did. The medical examiners’s office counted a total of 4,481 deaths from such non-natural causes that year, which – as Norris also noted – was pretty average for the city.

Culled from: The Poisoner’s Handbook: Murder and the Birth of Forensic Medicine in Jazz Age New York

 

Atrocious Archives!

If you’re bored, why not peruse the NYC Department of Records Online Collections?  So much to obsess over!

Almhouse Ledgers!
Bodies in Transit Registers!
Fire Department Photos!

and, most fascinatingly of all,
NYPD & Criminal Prosecution

(Thanks to Michael Marano for the tip.)

MFDJ 02/17/2019: All About Dwale

Today’s Bitter-Tasting Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

Before the advent of general anaesthesia, it is generally believed, a patient undergoing an operation could have expected little in the way of support other than from the bottle or from an ability to “bite the bullet.” But there is compelling evidence of an earlier age of anaesthesia. Descriptions of anaesthetics based on mixtures of medicinal herbs have been found in manuscripts dating from before Roman times until well into the Middle Ages. Most originated in regions of southern Europe where the relevant herbs grew naturally. A typical one, dated 800 AD, from the Benedictine monastery at Monte Cassino in southern Italy, used a mixture of opium, henbane, mulberry juice, lettuce, hemlock, mandragora, and ivy.

There is no evidence to suggest that similar recipes existed in the British Isles at that time. However, in 1992, an extensive study succeeded in identifying a large number of similar recipes in late medieval (12th-15th century) English manuscripts. All identified the anaesthetic, a drink, by the name dwale. A typical manuscript, translated into modern English, reads:

How to make a drink that men call dwale to make a man sleep whilst men cut him: take three spoonfuls of the gall [bile] of a barrow swine [boar] for a man, and for a woman of a gilt [sow], three spoonfuls of hemlock juice, three spoonfuls of wild neep [bryony], three spoonfuls of lettuce, three spoonfuls of pape [opium], three spoonfuls of henbane, and three spoonfuls of eysyl [vinegar], and mix them all together and boil them a little and put them in a glass vessel well stopped and put thereof three spoonfuls into a potel of good wine and mix it well together.

When it is needed, let him that shall be cut sit against a good fire and make him drink thereof until he fall asleep and then you may safely cut him, and when you have done your cure and will have him awake, take vinegar and salt and wash well his temples and his cheekbones and he shall awake immediately.

In addition to alcohol, the ingredients in dwale are, in order of their listing, bile, hemlock, bryony, lettuce, opium, henbane, and vinegar…  The seven ingredients in the dwale recipe can be divided into two broad groups, those in the first group being harmless and ineffectual (bile, lettuce, vinegar, and bryony root), and those in the second being powerful and dangerous (hemlock, opium, and henbane). Ingesting as little as 1 ml of hemlock juice can prove fatal; 3.5 ml opium (normal concentration 4-12% morphine alkaloids) would come close to, or exceed, the fatal dose of around 300 mg, and a similar volume of henbane (normally 0.25-0.5% concentration) would contain 8.75-17.5 mg of hyoscine alkaloids, enough to kill a child. The alcohol in the wine itself cannot be ignored.

However, dwale might not have been quite as dangerous as would at first sight appear. Medicinal herbs grown in northern countries are less potent than those grown in sunnier regions. As their potency is greatest when herbs are freshly collected, much would have been lost in the boiling and storage that the recipe calls for.

Most importantly, the recipe only asks him that “shall be cut” to drink until he falls asleep. A potel (2.276 litres) is the equivalent today of three bottles of wine. It seems most unlikely that the patient would have drunk this entire amount, particularly as the presence of bile and vinegar in the mixture would have given it a bitter taste. The amount consumed would have been enormously variable, and it is this variability in dose that would have made dwale so dangerously unpredictable.


What a Hangover… 

Culled from: National Institute of Health

Vintage Ophthalmological Images Du Jour!

Colored woodcuts from George Bartisch’s Ophthalmodouleia, published 1583.  

 

A woman with an enlarged and protruding eyeball and a man with sutured eyelids.


A man with metal clamps on his upper eyelids, perhaps to hold them open, and a man with metal clamps hanging from his upper eyelids, perhaps to close them down.

Culled from: Crucial Interventions: An Illustrated Treatise on the Principles & Practice of Nineteenth-Century Surgery

MFDJ 02/08/2019: Brotherly Love on the W. R. Carter

Today’s Red-Hot Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

The steamer glided through the cold night, every bend in the river a gentle turn. Louisiana starboard, Mississippi portside, New Orleans just a day ahead. The clean rushing air muffled the churn of engines and smoke. As children, Randall and Hart Gibson had made the journey downriver dozens of times. Though the W. R. Carterwas one of the newest additions to the Atlantic & Mississippi Steamship fleet, the voyage took the brothers back to more innocent days. It was an island of calm in a troubled world.

On February 2, 1866, as the steamer approached Vicksburg and the ancestral “Gibson neighborhood,” Randall could barely sleep. He stayed up until midnight talking with an old friend and then awoke in his stateroom at half past two. Hart was also awake, so they chatted until three. Randall “concluded to make one more effort to sleep,” and his brother went outside to smoke. Randall shut his eyes and drifted off. 

Just an hour later Randall was jolted from bed, gasping for air. The doors, windows, and floor planks of his room burst apart in a “tremendous explosion,” and the room filled with “scalding steam.” The ship’s massive boilers had blown, and with “wonderful rapidity,” Randall observed, “the flames swallowed up everybody and everything.” Suffocating and blind in the “intense smoke and darkness,” Randall “made a desperate lunge” to get outside. He could hear nothing but screaming. Two men rushed past him, calling for him to join them as they leaped off the deck. Randall hesitated, and for a moment “a gust of wind blew the steam and smoke aside.” To his horror, Randall saw that the men had not jumped overboard – instead they had fallen “into a crater, where many others were vainly struggling, but being rapidly burned to death. They had jumped right on the red hot boiler.” Randall lost his footing but grabbed a rope and swung past what he called the “devouring crater of flames.” “I thought the spectacle surpassed any description of Hades i had ever read or seen,” he later wrote. “The cries of desperation, of despair… were heart-rending.” It was worse than what he had seen at Shiloh, Chickamauga, and Spanish Fort as a General during the Civil War.

 

Randall Gibson during the Civil War

Just past the crater, a fellow passenger grabbed Randall, yelled, “Is that you, General? God bless you!” and pulled him to the edge of what remained of the ship. With flames at his back, Randall plunged into the Mississippi. In a river “so cold that it burned like fire,” pulled by its “irresistible” current, Randall grabbed at a bobbing cotton bale.Although it was four in the morning, the inferno cast a great light that could be seen miles away. Dozens of burning and drowning men and women were shrieking for help, as a deadly barrage of bolts, bars, stovepipes, and planks pierced air and water. Randall saw a half-submerged lifeboat. As he swam toward it, he saw it was holding four scalded men. Randall climbed in, bailed the boat out, and fought the current with a stray plank.  Slowly the boat made its way to shore, but it was taking on water. For half an hour Randall paddled as hard as he could, trying to get close enough to the shore that no one would drown when the lifeboat sank. When they finally abandoned the boat, there were roots to grab on to, and people on land soon pulled them to safety.

Soaking wet, dressed only in a flannel nightshirt, Randall watched the W. R. Carterburn to the waterline. Everything was gone – clothes, money, watches. He could not find his brother. 

A boat came to shore, carrying people and corpses pulled from the river. Randall climbed on board, looking for Hart among the survivors. Calling his name and asking for help, he was guided to a body among the dead, “wrapped up in a blanket, wholly unconscious and insensible, and in a rigid state.” The skin on Hart’s hands had been burned off. His feet were bare. Randall knelt by his brother and touched his chest – frozen. If Randall’s mind emptied as felt his loss, he was jolted back by a beat under his hand. And another. Hart lived.

Hart Gibson

Randall told several men to start rubbing his brother’s body, and they covered Hart’s feet with hot water bottles. [Where did they get hot water bottles at the edge of the river at dawn? – The Puzzled Comtesse] He plied Hart with an all-purpose remedy during the war, brandy and camphor. For an hour Randall knelt over his brother, working, giving orders as if he were still a general. Slowly, he would remember, Hart “came to himself.” After feeling utterly powerless, Randall had used his hands – his touch- to bring his brother back from the dead. The two men picked themselves up from the slick wet floor of the boat. They sat side by side as night turned to day. 

Culled from: The Invisible Line: A Secret History of Race in America


Garretdom: A Whirling Pillar of Flame

A special thanks to Howard Presser for sending in this doozy of a vintage news article!   (Oh, and isn’t the font in the headline nifty?  I wish we still used interesting fonts in newspapers.  Sigh…)

Culled from the Allentown Leader, Monday, June 22, 1908.

MFDJ 02/04/2019: Tenement Living, 19th Century Style

I want to thank everyone who has expressed words of encouragement and sympathy over the loss of my family’s house in my home town of Paradise, California.  They are most appreciated. 

I wanted to clear up a misconception: I wasn’t actually living in the house.  I currently live in Chicago.  My brother was living there and I had planned to return there eventually, but the house was where I grew up and and where all of the precious things that belonged to my deceased parents were stored.  I loved that house and every inch of that property, especially the immense pine trees that are all fatally injured. In a way, I feel that I have lost my parents all over again, along with my past and my future.  I am going through a lot of grief and processing it as best I can as I continue to work tirelessly on an inventory of all the items in the house for insurance purposes.

I hope that I will have the energy to devote to my hobbies on a full-time basis again soon.  Thank you for your patience.


Today’s Impoverished Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

Between 1890 and 1900 Greater New York added about 1 million persons to its population. By 1900 over a third of New Yorkers – nearly 1.3 million – were foreign-born, and 84 percent of the city’s white heads of families were either of foreign birth or the children of immigrants.

The new arrivals and the city’s poor packed into the ill-maintained tenements of lower Manhattan. There, ten people might share a single interior room without access to light or fresh air. The toilet often consisted of little more than a single latrine out back used by as many as two hundred people. To climb a dark staircase one risked stepping on playing children or becoming the victim of faceless attackers. In 1890 Jacob Riis had documented the plight of tenement dwellers in his How the Other Half Lives, taking haunting photos that lit the darkest corners of the Bowery with the new technology of flash photography. Homeless children and exhausted laborers renting a place on the floor for a nickel stared back at the camera.

 

The conditions on the Lower East Side became unbearable during the summer. To avoid the stifling tenement air, the inhabitants stayed outdoors on doorsteps and roofs, even sleeping there at night, hoping to catch the faintest breeze. In summers, families would keep ice stocked not only to prevent food from spoiling but also to bring down overheated body temperatures. The economic crisis of 1896 had made matters worse, as laboring families were so impoverished they could not afford to purchase ice.

Work in the home compounded the squalor. Tenement rooms doubled as places of work for cigar makers and other pieceworkers, including children. When in the 1880s a bill had come before the New York State Assembly forbidding the manufacture of cigars in tenements, labor leader Samuel Gompers had taken a young assemblyman named Theodore Roosevelt on a tour of the Lower East Side. Roosevelt had not believed the horror stories about the tenements, and Gompers meant to educate the wealthy brownstone Republican. Accompanied by Gompers, Roosevelt came into contact with the city’s poor for the first time, and years later he remembered:

There were one, two, or three room apartments, and the work went on day and night in the eating, living, and sleeping rooms – sometimes in one room. I have always remembered one room in which two families were living. On my inquiry as to who the third adult male was I was told that he was a boarder with one of the families. There were several children, three men, and two women in this room. The tobacco was stowed about everywhere, alongside the foul bedding, and in a corner where there were scraps of food. The men, women, and children in this room worked by day and far on into the evening, and they slept and ate there.

Bohemian Cigarmakers at work in their Tenement

Tenement dwellers daily faced a precarious economic situation. New York’s Lower East Side was dominated by the expanding needle trade, one of the fastest-growing sectors of New York manufacturing. The vast majority of the contractors had their shops below Fourteenth Street, within easy walking distance of the tenements. In 1890, before the slump, 10,000 garment firms had employed around 236,000 workers. In early 1896 the tailors of New York went on strike for more pay against the wealthier contractors who filled orders for the large clothing companies. In good times a tailor might have made $12 or $15 a week, but during the depression he was often lucky to receive only half a week’s work. Now 20,000 tailors, all members of the Brotherhood of Tailors union, were out of work. This meant that about 100,000 residents of the tenements clustered around the intersection of Hester and Essex Streets were without means of support. A reporter walking along Hester Street at night found “at least half of the population of that street seeking sleep on the fire escapes, the stairways or the doorsteps. In most cases, fighting for air, they had carried their blankets and mattresses from their dens, but often I found men and women scantily clothed sleeping, or trying in vain to sleep, upon bare wood or iron, glad of the fresh air – fresh only by comparison with the evil atmosphere of their living rooms.”


“‘Let’s move to America,’ he said.  ‘Land of Opportunity,’ he said.”

The strike had left the tailors in a desperate situation. Local grocers and merchants stopped extending credit to the strikers. Thousands were forced to sustain themselves with “bad fruit, questionable meat, and stale bread,” one New York paper noted. Bad air and bad food combined to make many sick, though they were unable to afford a doctor. Esther Greenhaum lived in a tenement on Essex Street and had fallen very ill. Her husband, a striking tailor, failed to return home, apparently ashamed he could not provide for his wife. [How thoughtful of him. – DeSpair]  Not wanting to ask her neighbors for help, Esther suffered in her room quietly until she cried out in pain. Hearing this, a neighbor summoned a doctor, who asked if Esther could pay his fee. “Yes,” the neighbor woman lied, “she will pay,” knowing that this was the only way to lure the doctor to the tenement. When Esther could not pay, the doctor became enraged. The neighbor cut him off, saying, “God will pay. No one else can.”

Culled from: Hot Time in the Old Town: The Great Heat Wave of 1896 and the Making of Theodore Roosevelt

If you ever find yourself bored in New York City, do not neglect to visit the Lower East Side Tenement Museum, which brilliantly documents the hard lives of immigrants in the tenement blocks.  Highly recommended!


Morbid Trinket Du Jour!

Lissa writes to let me know of a lovely Morbid Trinket:

“If anyone is attending school, has morbid offspring, or would just like a really cool journal, check this out.”

 

Available at Amazon and probably many other places as well.