Today’s Grifting Yet Truly Morbid Fact!
Early Tuesday morning, July 16, 1912, New York City was sweating through a brutal heat wave. Gambler Herman “Beansie” Rosenthal was spending his last earthly moments in the Hotel Metropole, a popular gathering spot for the sporting set, at 143 West Forty-Third Street. He was nursing his beverage of choice: a horse’s neck—cold ginger ale with a lemon twist. The next day he was scheduled to appear before a grand jury to tell all he knew about the illegal gambling taking place in Manhattan. There were a lot of people on both sides of the law who would have preferred that Rosenthal keep his mouth shut.
Around two A.M. he was told that he was wanted outside. Rosenthal obligingly complied, striding through the lobby toward the street, where he was summoned by name. When he approached a man in the shadows, he was hit by four gunshots—one in the neck, one in the nose, and two in the head. Four gunmen sped off in a gray Packard, leaving Rosenthal to die in the sweltering street.
During the months leading up to his murder, Rosenthal’s fortunes were on the downturn. The previous autumn, he borrowed $5,000 from “Big” Tim Sullivan, the powerful Tammany Hall politician who controlled gambling operations in the Tenderloin, the rough-and-tough neighborhood that had expanded to surround Times Square. At one time, Rosenthal had run the popular gaming room at Sullivan’s famed Hesper Club. Rosenthal hoped to recapture his lost prestige by opening a new, luxurious casino at 104 West Forty-Fifth Street. The club, however, was shuttered just four days after it opened. Cops, under the command of Inspector Cornelius Hayes, raided the joint because, according to Rosenthal, he refused to pay the policemen the necessary tribute to stay in business.
Since nobody made money when a casino closed down, Rosenthal reluctantly reached out to Lieutenant Charles Becker. He was the commander of one of the NYPD’s three Strong Arm Squads, which were special units formed by Police Commissioner Rhinelander Waldo to suppress vice in the Tenderloin. To most casual observers, Becker seemed to perform his job with great enthusiasm, but to those in the know, Becker could be bought. Rosenthal wanted to know if some arrangement could be worked out. Becker agreed, provided Rosenthal cut him in on the action.
Unfortunately, Becker could not give Rosenthal complete immunity from prosecution. When Police Commissioner Waldo gave Becker a direct order to raid Rosenthal’s nightclub on April 17, 1912, he had no choice but to comply. Although Becker arranged for Rosenthal to be away from the casino, he arrested Rosenthal’s teenaged nephew. The nephew’s subsequent indictment, and his own inability to reopen his gambling den, outraged Rosenthal. This set him and Becker on a collision course that would cost both of them their lives.
Since Becker could not, or would not, help him, Rosenthal decided to turn on him. He took his grievances to the Manhattan district attorney, Charles Whitman, a priggish prosecutor with political ambitions. At first, Whitman ignored his caterwauling until Herbert Bayard Swope, a young and ambitious newspaperman for Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World, obtained Rosenthal’s signed affidavit spelling out Becker’s outsized appetite for graft.
With Rosenthal now lying on a morgue slab, Whitman was left in an unenviable quandary. Who had killed Rosenthal, and how could Whitman now prosecute Becker, a purportedly dirty cop, without a star witness?
The solution became apparent when Whitman, at Swope’s urging, granted immunity to four suspects the police apprehended who admitted playing key roles in the scheme. Three of those suspects—Jack “Bald Jack Rose” Rosenzweig, Louis “Bridgey” Webber, and Harry Vallon—testified that they hired the getaway car and the shooters. They were ostensibly paid $1,000 at Becker’s behest to do the hit. Becker even pointed out Rosenthal in front of the Metropole for the assassins.
Bald Jack’s claims were particularly devastating to Becker. He alleged that upon seeing Rosenthal’s lifeless body, Becker remarked, “It was a pleasing sight to me to look and see that squealing Jew there, and if it were not for the presence of Whitman, I would have cut out his tongue and hung it up on the Times building as a warning to future squealers.”
The four shooters, all members of the Lenox Avenue Gang, were not afforded any leniency by Whitman. Harry “Gyp the Blood” Horowitz, Louis “Lefty Louie” Rosenberg, Francisco “Dago Frank” Cirofici, and Jacob “White Lewis” Seidenshiner were convicted and subsequently electrocuted an April 13, 1914.
“Lefty Louis” Rosenberg and Gyp the Blood (seated in front row) after being arrested by police (standing)
Becker was tried separately. Although he did not testify on his own behalf, much was made by the prosecution of the fact that he had deposited nearly $30,000 in several different banks during the months leading up to Rosenthal’s murder. His various convoluted explanations about how he accumulated to much money in such a short period of time (on a salary of $2,000 a year) only made him seem more dishonest. He was found guilty and sentenced to die. However, a scathing Court of Appeals ruling in February 1914 tossed out the verdict and ordered a new trial on the grounds that Judge John W. Goff had been biased against him and his defense team.
A new judge, the esteemed Samuel Seabury, presided over a retrial that ended with the same results. Becker was again found guilty and sentenced to death. This time, the courts declined to intervene.
While waiting for his appointment with death in Sing Sing’s bleak “Death House,” Becker became friendly with a fellow death row inmate as notorious as himself, Father Hans Schmidt, the only Catholic priest in America ever to be sentenced to death.
Becker insisted he was innocent until the very end. “I am not guilty by deed, or conspiracy, or any other way, of the death of Rosenthal,” Becker announced, as he prepared to die. Becker’s third wife, the former Helen Lynch, a public school teacher, had petitioned the governor to spare her husband’s life. Unfortunately for her, the newly elected governor was none other than Charles Whitman, the very same prosecutor who had twice convicted Becker. His sentence was carried out in what witnesses described as a “botched” electrocution because it required more than eight agonizing minutes for Becker to die.
Charles Becker’s Mugshot at Sing-Sing
In response, Mrs. Becker became so outraged, she arranged to have a silver plate engraved with the inscription affixed to her husband’s coffin. It read, “Charles Becker. Murdered July 30, 1915. By Governor Whitman.” It was only after the threat of arrest for criminal libel that the plate was removed prior to Becker’s burial at Woodlawn Cemetery in the Bronx.
Several authors have argued how Becker was likely innocent and was framed with manufactured evidence by the opportunists Swope and Whitman. Rosenthal’s obstreperousness made him a tempting target, not only for Becker but for other corrupt cops and unsavory gamblers, many of whom were incensed he would take a private spat public, as well as the politicians they paid off to stay in business.
Culled from: Undisclosed Files of the Police
The Hotel Metropole building is still standing – albeit much less charming than it used to be. It is now the Casablanca restaurant.
Weegee Du Jour!
Weegee was the pseudonym of Arthur Fellig (June 12, 1899 – December 26, 1968), a photographer and photojournalist, known for his stark black and white street photography. Weegee worked in Manhattan, New York City’s Lower East Side as a press photographer during the 1930s and ’40s, and he developed his signature style by following the city’s emergency services and documenting their activity. Much of his work depicted unflinchingly realistic scenes of urban life, crime, injury and death.
Here’s a photo from the book Weegee’s New York: Photographs, 1935-1960:
“Mail Early for Delivery Before Christmas”
Andersonville Prisoner Diary Entry Du Jour!
This is the continuation of the 1864 diary of Andersonville prisoner Private George A. Hitchcock (see the archived version for all entries up until now).
Here’s today’s entry:
July 3d. Very hot. Roll was called throughout the camp. Our detachment lost their rations on account of the absence of half a dozen men, so our extra rations of yesterday were very opportune.
Culled from: Andersonville: Giving Up the Ghost