Alferd Packer Massacre Site (Lake City, Colorado)
Visit the infamous location where America’s Fine Young Cannibal, Alferd Packer, did some human meat packing back in 1874. (Thanks to The Quiet One for the suggestion.)

Hinsdale County Museum (Lake City, Colorado)
Per Roadside America: “In downtown Lake City stands the Hinsdale County Museum, which boasts the most extensive collection of Alferd Packer memorabilia known. Included is a skull fragment from one of his victims, a pair of shackles used on Alferd when he was in the Lake City jail, and a number of buttons from the clothes of the five men he eventually ate. Sadly, the butcher knife found sticking in the thigh of Frank Miller (a Packer entree), has disappeared.” (Thanks to The Quiet One for the suggestion.)