Morbid Fact Du Jour For March 1, 2011

Today’s morbid fact is a bit of philosophical musing by Colin Wilson in his (actually not very good) book The Mammoth Book of True Crime. I found it interesting and thought you might as well?

Today’s Hair-Raising Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

T.S. Duke’s Celebrated Criminal Cases of America (1910) contains a hair-raising account of “The Outrages Committed by the Sioux Indians” between 1852 and 1862, with details of rapes and mutilations that would have convinced any reader that the Sioux deserved mass extermination. Nowadays, civilized opinion has swung the other way; it was the white men who were the criminals; the Indian was only trying to defend his own right to live. Yet when we read Duke’s account today, we are less concerned with the rights and wrongs than with the unreducible human tragedy:

The hero of the day was an 11-year-old boy named Martin Eastlick, who carried his 15-month-old brother Johnny on his back for 50 miles, but he died shortly afterwards from exposure, over-exertion and lack of nourishment. Mr. Eastlick had been killed and Mrs. Eastlick was lying helpless on the ground from a bullet wound. Her two little boys named Freddie and Frank, aged five and seven respectively, were with her. Two squaws saw them, and catching the children they beat them to death with bludgeons before the helpless mother’s eyes. Many other children were only beaten until they were left helpless and then left to die from hunger and exposure.

Thirty-eight Indians were tried and executed for the massacres. They would have argued that it was unfair to treat the massacre as a ‘crime’, since they were at war with the white man, and the white man had treated Indian women and children just as brutally. In retrospect we can see that it makes no difference whether it was called an act of war or a crime, for they are synonymous. The only logical course, it seems, is to recognize that murder is always unjustified, whether it is a criminal act or an act of war.

Culled from: The Mammoth Book Of True Crime by Colin Wilson

So, do you agree with Colin? Is murder always unjustified?

6 comments

  1. good question, i personally think some are.. look at johnny stompanato. i think cheryl was justified.

  2. Desmond Tutu once made the comment that nonviolence does not always work. The example he used was Hitler-and indeed if someone just refused to fight the state apparatus of the Nazis, they would be killed. (The Nazis were happy to oblige people in that way.) In a situation where your existence itself were threatened, by a person or group who felt they were doing the world a favor by getting rid of you, what choice wouldyou have? If you have a family with children, do you kill to keep them alive, or do you make the choice for them and choose to die instead.
    While I believe the violence perpetrated on the Indians by whites and vice versa never should have been committed, its a hard question to answer. I would like to think there is never a good reason to kill, but as someone with three children I know I would do whatever it took to protect their lives, if not my own.

  3. I read that book and I liked it a lot. Some people find that type of book style to be choppy but I’ve always enjoyed it. It’s pretty old, isn’t it? I read it in 1994 and 1995 and as I recall the most recent cases in it were from the early seventies.
    As to the question at hand, both sides committed atrocities. It really doesn’t matter that much who started it. Once somebody does start it they have no right to expect the other side won’t pick it up. Maybe it’s not right, maybe they don’t deserve what comes in return, but what’s right and the whole concept of deserve don’t have anything to do with it. Once things are set in motion, that stuff is mainly academic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *