Morbid Fact Du Jour For March 17, 2011

Today’s Fabricated Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

 Home Of The Rebel SharpshooterAmong the earliest and best-known photographs of war dead in America is Alexander Gardner’s “Home of the Rebel Sharpshooter, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, 1863”. It is not possible to reconstruct the impact this particular image had upon people in the 1860s or even to conjecture about how many people might have seen the picture. But among those who did see the image, there is no written evidence that anyone doubted its veracity. That faith in its verisimilitude no longer exists. William Frassanito has demonstrated that Gardner and his colleagues organized “reality”. He moved the dead soldier and his weapons into a more compositionally pleasing position and used the same body for at least two different photographs. Apparently, Gardner believed the photograph would be more effective if it were composed in this manner. Some have argued that the falsification of photographs during the Civil War was necessary for a greater good: “The photograph readily became the vehicle for moral truth. If expression of this truth required mistitling an image, misinterpreting it, or even interfering physically with what was being photographed to achieve a more effective image, it was entirely justifiable.”

Culled from: Secure The Shadow: Death and Photography in America

So, what do you think?  Is it okay to alter reality to make a more “pleasing” composition… or is Truth more important?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *