Today’s Karmic Yet Truly Morbid Fact!
Matt Tarpy hated to see crime and disorder. An Irish immigrant, Tarpy came to California during the Gold Rush and settled beside the Pajaro River near Watsonville. A diehard racist, Tarpy seemed to hate everyone, but he had a special hatred for the Californios. To him, they were all thieves, cutthroats and bandits. Tarpy was a natural leader and he used his organizational skills to bring his version of law and order to the Pajaro Valley and the Monterey Bay area, whether the residents agreed with him or not.
Tarpy first made a name for himself as a vigilante in October 1856, when he captured the notorious outlaw Juan Salazar. Salazar had escaped from the Santa Barbara jail and stolen a herd of horses while making his getaway. He joined up with some of his bandit friends and drove the horses north to the Pajaro River. Salazar and a comrade stayed at Salazar’s ex-wife’s home, while his gang camped out near the river.
Tarpy and his rancher buddies heard that Salazar was nearby and quickly found the outlaw camp. Entering the cabin, they found Salazar in bed and captured him without a struggle. His friend escaped, as a hail of bullets whizzed past him.
Tarpy and his posse intended to take Salazar to Watsonville, but as they traveled through a dense grove of wild mustard, Salazar allegedly made a break for it. Tarpy and his friends filled him with lead.
At daybreak, Tarpy and his men arrived in Watsonville with Salazar’s dead body lying over the back of a horse. A half dozen vaqueros happened to be entering Watsonville at the same time. Tarpy and his company thought that they were Salazar’s gang and ordered them to halt. Who fired first is lost to history; however, the Californio cowboys fired some shots, Tarpy’s gang fired some shots, and general mayhem commenced.
The Californios, realizing that it wasn’t a good time to visit Watsonville, rode their horses out of town at a full gallop, with Tarpy’s gang in hot pursuit. The vaqueros outran the vigilantes, but Tarpy found a blood trail from a wounded horse and his gang followed it to a house a few miles from Watsonville. They apprehended a man with dried blood on his boots into custody and took him back into town.
Tarpy tied the vaquero to a flagpole in the center of town, where he was subsequently identified by Tarpy’s group as one of the Californios. The citizens of Watsonville, Anglos and Californios alike, argued about the fate of the man, causing great tension in the dusty town. The prisoner claimed self-defense, and many of the citizens of Watsonville agreed that Tarpy and his pals had fired first. Watsonville had been a settlement for nine years and the residents weren’t happy about having a greenhorn, racist Irishman and his irrational followers acting as judge, jury, and executioner in their area.
The next morning, the consensus of the townsfolk was that the prisoner would be handed over to the authorities in San Jose. Tarpy was fervently opposed to the plan, so he freed the prisoner, who ran to his vaquero friends and rode off into the hills. Tarpy and his gang jumped on their horses in pursuit. A running gunfight broke out, but Tarpy’s gang managed to capture the poor vaquero again. Instead of taking him to San Jose, they hung him from a tree along the riverbank.
After that incident, Tarpy decided that he was indeed the law of the land, much to the dismay of the people who lived in the area. For the next sixteen years, the residents of Santa Cruz and Monterey counties had to live with the fact that a psychopathic, egomaniacal Irish rancher and a handful of like-minded Anglos dealt out the law according to their own wishes.
There is no way of knowing just how many men Tarpy and his gang lynched, but it is believed that the number included at the very least fifteen Indians and Hispanics. He basically hunted down and shot anyone he thought was a rustler, which to Tarpy meant anyone who wasn’t the correct hue of white and didn’t speak English.
Tarpy’s reign of terror lasted until 1873. The locals, disgusted by the years of Tarpy’s racism, tyranny, and brutality, finally had enough of the vigilante after the thug shot a woman named Sarah Nicholson with whom he had a land dispute.
Tarpy took his arrest lightly, figuring that nobody would actually convict him. Imagine his surprise when a crowd of over four hundred Anglos, Californios, and Hispanics broke into the Monterey jail in the middle of the night and took him captive. They took him three miles out of town in a wagon and hung him from a tree. A Californio placed the noose around Tarpy’s neck before they jerked him up into the damp ocean air.
Culled from: California Justice: Shootouts, Lynchings and Assassinations in the Golden State by David Kulczyk
Incidentally, David Kulczyk has a new book out. I’ve just started it and it’s as fun and readable as his other books. I’ll give a full review when I’m done.
California Fruits, Flakes, and Nuts: True Tales of California Crazies, Crackpots and Creeps