Today’s Athletic Yet Truly Morbid Fact!
1931 was the deadliest year in football history. Here’s the tale of some of the fatalities.
Leon Carey, a freshman defensive back for the obscure institution of Monticello A & M had the singular honor of inaugurating the year’s collegiate carnage. During practice on September 17, while flattening a ball-carrier during a drill, he took a knee to the head. Smack! The blow didn’t even faze him. He finished practice and even ate dinner that evening. But later that night, he collapsed with a cerebral hemorrhage. He died a few days later.
The second college player went down even before Carey finished dying. While practicing on September 19, someone cut down Wayne Merrifield of Michigan State Normal with a nifty, nasty block to the knees on a punt. And this block was very nasty. Merrifield’s knee was hopelessly shattered. That alone was enough to free up one position in the starting line-up. However, Merrifield was out for more than the season. Early the next morning, his knee injury triggered a “coronary fat embolism” that killed him in his hospital bed. Nice blocking, no? And this is just practice for the real thing!
The pre-season winnowing over, players began to lay down their lives for their beloved alma mater in earnest. The laurels for the first player killed in an actual game were apparently won by a high school player: William Maher, a fullback for the Oakland (California) High Wildcats. During a September 25 match-up with cross-town rivals Fremont High, the highly-regarded running back more than lived up to his star billing. He smashed through the beleaguered Tiger line repeatedly, leaving a stream of gangly adolescent guards and acne-scarred tackles sprawled in his wake. Even from the distance of 66 years, it’s not too hard to understand the secret of his success. He was 20 years old, running wild over a field full of teenagers. Can you say “eligibility”?
At the end of the first quarter, Maher scored a touchdown on a line plunge. Crunch! For an encore, he smashed through the tackles again for the conversion. Pow! The coach decided things were sufficiently well-in-hand to let his chief asset take a rest and give other, more expendable, players a chance. Maher hadn’t given the least sign of distress or mentioned any discomfort to his teammates. But as he trotted towards the sideline, the coach saw his worst nightmare come true – the death of a star player. The stunned gridiron general later told the papers, “He was walking towards the bench when he suddenly collapsed.” Thump! Maher was later pronounced dead of a cerebral hemorrhage. Apparently some of his under-sized adolescent opposition had sneaked in a few good licks of their own. At least Oakland managed to hold on and escape with a 27-0 victory.
Maher’s rapid demise barely edged out another high school boy, Cason Nabors. The same day Maher died, Nabors was knocking the opposition around two thousand miles away in Alabama. Unfortunately, one sloppily executed block wound up with an upended blockee landing right on Nabors’ stomach. Ooof! Nabors died two days later of a ruptured intestine.
The next day, on September 26, the intercollegiate season received its baptism. In their season opener against Valparaiso University, Elmhurst College captain Reuben Gretschow led half of the Pirate defense in gang tackling an opposing end. Smack! Down went the players in a welter of colored jerseys and leather helmets. But when officials finally untangled the pile-up, Gretschow remained motionless on the field. He was paralyzed, but not dead, from a fractured 4th vertebrae.
The next day, Gretschow told reporters defiantly, “Don’t think a little thing like a broken neck is going to get the best of me.” Oddly enough this was not entirely idle chatter by a jock befuddled by big words like “negative prognosis.” Rueben knew spinal fractures. He had broken his neck in a construction accident four years earlier and recovered. Why, he’d be out there next year, busting heads like nothing happened!
Orthodox medical opinion was justifiably more pessimistic. The plucky captain’s condition steadily deteriorated. By the following Saturday, his condition was so grave doctors kept the news of his teammates’ stirring victory over Milwaukee State Teacher’s College from him. They feared that telling him something that would make his heart race might be fatal.
Even this precaution was for naught . Rueben died the next day, innocent of both his teammate’s stirring triumph and his no-doubt Gipper-like role in it.
[To be continued]
Culled from: Murder Can Be Fun #18 by John Marr
Car Crash Du Jour!
One of my favorite books is Car Crashes and Other Sad Stories by Anaheim photographer Mell Kilpatrick. It’s a collection of car crash photos from the 40’s and 50’s, often with corpses still strewn across the enormous interior (or out of it, since there were no seat belts in those days). It combines my love of old cars with my love of morbidity and is the perfect ambulance chaser book!

