MFDJ 07/14/23: Iron Mike Malloy, Part 2

Today we conclude the amazing story of Iron Mike Malloy.  (Here’s Part 1, in case you missed it.)

Today’s Ill-Conceived Yet Truly Morbid Fact!

The morning after Mike Malloy’s death, a Dr Frank Manzella came to the room. For a $100 fee, he signed a death certificate for “Nicholas Mellory,” the pseudonym the conspirators had used on Malloy’s insurance policy, citing “lobar pneumonia” as the cause of death.  Manzella also falsely claimed that Malloy had been to his doctor’s office in Harlem twice before his death, complaining of “grippe,” which he listed as a contributory cause of death, along with acute bronchitis.


The forged death certificate

With Manzella’s fake as proof of death, Metropolitan Life paid out the $800 policy on Mellory. As a final insult, Frank Pasqua wrote out a $400 check to impress insurance agents with the lavish funeral he was preparing for his dear friend.  In reality, he stuck Mike Malloy in a $10 coffin and buried him in a $12 grave. He didn’t even bother to embalm his body – a final moment of greed and haste that would send them all to the electric chair.

On 18 March, ‘Tough’ Tony Bastone was shot dead. He was a local gangster, and acquainted with everyone at Marino’s speakeasy.  A Joseph Maglione was charged with his murder, and Red Murphy was taken into custody as a material witness.  When agents from Prudential tried to track down “Joseph Mellory” (Murphy’s alias as Malloy’s “brother”), and couldn’t find him in order to pay out the two remaining insurance policies, their suspicions were raised.

Meanwhile, the tall tale of Mike Malloy and the Murder Trust had spread like wildfire throughout the borough of the Bronx.  Soon enough, neighborhood cops got wind of it, and the District Attorney, Samuel Foley, started an investigation.  He ordered Mike Malloy’s body to be dug up, and given a proper autopsy.


Malloy’s body during autopsy

Unfortunately for Pasqua and the rest, forensic pathology and toxicology was a burgeoning science in New York of the 1930s.  When Dr Hochmann performed a full examination of Malloy’s body on 11 May, he found the tell-tale cherry-red discoloration all over his body.  The official verdict? “Asphyxiation by carbon monoxide.”  The irony, as outlined in Deborah Blum’s The Poisoner’s Handbook, is that if Pasqua had taken the time to embalm the body, the liquid would have removed all trace of the gas.

The next day, Marino, Murphy, Pasqua, Kreisberg and Green were arrested and charged with first-degree murder.  Green was already in custody on gun charges, likewise Kreisberg, who had been arrested on a separate robbery and assault charge.  Dr Frank Manzella, a former Republic Alderman in Harlem, was arrested and charged with being an accessory after the fact.


Francis Pasqua (left) and Tony Marino (right) 

Joseph Maglione, suspected of killing Tough Tony Bastone, managed to plead his murder charge down to manslaughter, saving himself from execution, in exchange for testifying against the Murder Trust.  By the time the trial began in October, Hershy Green had turned state’s witness, in exchange for the lesser charge of first-degree assault, for running over Murray in his taxi.  The four others tried every trick in the book to exonerate themselves. They turned on each other, claimed the witnesses testifying against them were actually in on the plot as well.

Pasqua’s lawyer tried to argue he was just the undertaker, and had nothing to do with the planning.  Murphy and Kreisberg both fingered each other as the one who gassed Malloy on 22 February. All except Marino claimed they were acting under the threats and intimidation of local tough guy Tony Bastone, saying he had forced them “at gunpoint” to kill Malloy and kick up the insurance money to him.  Foley, the prosecutor, dismissed this as “desperation,” pointing out that Frank Pasqua had confessed his role in the murder plot in May, two months after Bastone was himself shot dead.

Tony Marino, meanwhile, pleaded insanity.  His lawyer brought a doctor to the Bronx County Courthouse, who testified that a childhood fall, combined with a recent illness (probably syphilis), meant Marino had “become abnormal.”  Foley brought in a neurologist, however, who concluded he was “faking abnormality.”

Early on the morning of 19 October, a jury found all four guilty of first degree murder.  The New York Times reported that, in response to hearing the verdicts, Marino “glared angrily,” Kreisberg “swayed”, Pasqua “winced”, and Murphy “remained inscrutable.”   They were sentenced to death by electrocution, and driven off to Sing Sing prison in New York. In the prison van, they sang songs together, including the Jelly Roll Morton hit My Gal Sal.

Harry Green was given five to 10 years for his vehicular assault on Murray, and Frank Manzella, who was paid to write Nicholas Mellory’s fake death cert, was convicted of the lesser charge of failing to report a suspicious death.

On 7 June 1934, Tony Marino, Daniel Kreisberg, and Frank Pasqua were put to death on the electric chair.  Marino, the son of Italian immigrants and a married father to one child, was 28.  Kreisberg was 29, the son of Russian Jewish immigrants, and had a wife and three kids.  Frank Pasqua, the youngest of the group, was just 24 years old. In a bitter irony, his wedding a few years earlier had been conducted by James Barrett – the judge in his murder trial.

Two hours before he was due to die along with the others, Joseph Murphy got a reprieve from the Lieutenant Governor of New York, Michael William Bray.  Some startling new evidence had emerged. Joseph Murphy, it appeared, was born Archie Mott, an orphan, estranged from his family and unmarried.  A doctor who treated him in 1933 found him to be “mentally unbalanced.”  His lawyer had heard from an inmate at Sing Sing that Murphy was committed to the Connecticut School for Boys, under the name of Archie Mott, and had escaped in 1929.  Despite several reprieves for psychological testing, however, he was denied a retrial, and executed on 5 July. He was 28 years old.

Michael Malloy, the man himself, was reburied after the autopsy, at Ferncliff Cemetery in Hartsdale, New York. And that’s where he lies today – inside a $10 coffin, in a charity plot, with no headstone and no name.

Culled from: The Journal

 

Legend Du Jour!

Several centuries ago, something haunted a small fishing village huddled among the rockfalls fringing a Norwegian fjord.  For five long years, something wandered near the houses and wailed on the wind. A fisherman in the village was the first to discover what it was.

This is how he learned.  He lay one night among his family in their hut of toughly chinked logs, and on that night, although the wind mumbled around the walls, and rattled at the latch, no crying voice was heard and no footsteps pattered outside. For the first time in years, the only noises were natural ones, and the fisherman slept soundly.

In the small hours, however, he was roused by the goats that shared the family’s hut.  They had begun to shuffle uneasily in the straw.  He looked around with the heightened alertness of the suddenly awakened.  But nothing seemed amiss. The air was close with the fetor of animals and the breath of the sleeping children, nestled together for warmth. Beside him, his wife lay deep in dreams.

Then he saw what had disturbed the goats. A patch of moonlight fell on the back of the door, and in its light the fisherman discerned a thin thread of smoke uncoiling from the keyhole. The merest wisp of vapor, it sank lazily toward the floor, vanishing in the gloom. The man’s eyes strained to follow it and caught, near the base of the door, a glimmer uncannily like bare skin.

He watched transfixed as the faint luminosity resolved itself into human—or near-human—form. Crawling from the darkness, its skin blue with cold, its ribs starting from a withered torso and its wide eyes fastened on his own, was an apparition of his own child, an infant boy who had died five years before. The ghost approached across the straw-strewn floor in silence. Jolted into action at last, the man shook his wife awake. [Gee, thanks – The Wife]

She gave a whimper of recognition as the infant crept across her legs and belly. The man snatched at the small figure, thinking to pull it away, but his hands closed on a substance as cold, hard and inexorable as glacial ice. His wife gasped for breath as the weight of the ghost crushed her chest. The little arms reached for her face. Tiny hands churned for an instant in the mother’s eye sockets, and the next moment, the apparition was gone. The woman’s whimper rose to a scream, and blood welled where her eyes had been. She was blind. The following night, the wailing and the pattering in the lanes around the village began again—and would continue for many years.

The vengeful infant ghost that maimed its mother was known as an utburd, from the old Norse word for “child carried outside.” It had been born sickly into a family that already had too many mouths to feed, and it had been exposed. The fisherman and his wfie had scratched a shallow grave in the snowbound wilds outside their hamlet and left the child alone there to die and stiffen in the stinging cold. Death soon released the child’s spirit from the little body. Later that same day, the fisherman covered the grave.

He and his wife had felt no remorse. In the harsh lands of the North, it was common practice to expose infants in times of want, or when the mother was unwed or when the child was sickly or malformed. Justified though the act seemed to the adults who performed it, the ghosts that sprang from the tiny corpses burned for revenge. And, as if in compensation for the infants’ helplessness during their few days of life, utburds were formidable ghosts, gathering strength in the years after their deaths until they could make their vengeance complete.

Culled from: The Enchanted World: Ghosts

One comment

  1. Steven Spielberg took a shot at the Mike Malloy saga in his (mediocre) TV show “Amazing Stories” in 1986. In his version, of course, Mike outlives his would-be killers.
    Worth watching? No. The cutesy direction (a real problem with that show) left no doubt that Mike would survive – practically winking at the camera as he climbs out of the frozen river where his pals have dumped him. Sheer tedium.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *